Call Now:

(312) 609-0400

Call Us for Free Consultation

Call Now: (312) 609-0400

Close this search box.

Current Case Illustrates Absurdities in Workers’ Compensation System

Word absurdity printed on paper

or fill out the Contact Form

Governor Rauner has been trying to turn workers’ compensation reform into a wedge issue. He claims that exorbitant workers’ compensation insurance premiums are driving businesses and jobs out of Illinois, stifling growth and eliminating jobs. However, he fails to mention that the majority of litigation is driven by insurance companies and defense firms. We are in the midst of litigating a case that illustrates the reality of the situation.
Our client is a dockworker at ABF Freight Systems. He had been loading and unloading their trucks for years when he suffered a ruptured biceps tendon in his right arm. He reported his accident and sought prompt medical attention. He was cleared for surgery but wanted a second opinion – an absolute right under the workers’ compensation act.

Word absurdity printed on paper

However, once ABF’s insurance company and their attorneys got involved, the case immediately stalled. First, the insurance company had a nurse attend our client’s doctor’s appointment and tell him that, if he exercised his right to a second opinion, his treatment would be delayed. Next, ABF Freight, through its defense firm, hired a doctor to perform an examination and conclude that our client had not suffered an injury. The Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission had already determined, in a written decision, that this doctor had no credibility. However, ABF Freight, and their defense firm, were not bothered by this in the least.

Eventually, ABF forced our client to wait one year for trial by demanding additional depositions – even though the witness they insisted upon testified favorably for our client and against ABF.

Finally, almost two years (!) after the accident, we received an arbitration decision concluding what was apparent from the beginning – our client is entitled to financial and medical benefits under the Workers’ Compensation Act. As we write this, he has been without medical care and disability benefits for a year and a half and we are waiting to hear if the defense attorney will insist on a meaningless appeal – dragging the case out for another year.

Real disputes occur, and they should be heard and decided by impartial arbitrators. However, the problem arises when insurance companies and their defense firms purposefully delay simple proceedings in the hopes of scaring injured workers into accepting settlements. Our client was offered a pittance to resolve his claim before trial, even though it was clear that the evidence favored him. Now, as we wait for ABF Freight’s defense attorneys to appeal, we anticipate that, once they do so, they will again offer a pittance to settle. This tactic of attempting to starve injured workers into settlement is all too common.

So, the next time that you hear a politician or an insurance company lobbyist blame injured workers for problems with the Workers’ Compensation Commission, ask yourself who really benefits from the protracted litigation. It is not our client, who has waited two years for an operation with no medical care and no income. It is not us – the value of our fee actually decreases in cases like these. In contrast, the insurance company has now placed itself in a position where the operative repair may not be possible due to the delay, saving them medical costs, and ABF Freight’s defense firm has billed thousands of dollars on a case that never should have been litigated. So, who are the real winners and losers here? Who is incentivized to prolong litigation and keep the dockets full?

Share This Article

As the founder of the firm, Neal has devoted his life to working for the worker. His achievements are numerous and beyond reproach. He is most proud of his work in helping clients obtain valuable benefits, such as a wheelchair ramp to his home or lifetime medical care.

or fill out the Contact Form

As the founder of the firm, Neal has devoted his life to working for the worker. His achievements are numerous and beyond reproach. He is most proud of his work in helping clients obtain valuable benefits, such as a wheelchair ramp to his home or lifetime medical care.

Related Articles

Construction worker has an accident while working on new house. Most common workplace injuries
Workers' Compensation

10 Most Common Workplace Injuries in Chicago, Illinois

Workplace injuries occur daily in nearly all types of jobs. Some workplace injuries are minor and heal within a short time. Others are severe and life-threatening, leaving the injured worker with permanent disabilities, emotional trauma, and financial difficulties. Most workplace injuries can be prevented by prioritizing safety. Unfortunately, a 2021 Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) report shows that 102,000 and 22,700 non-fatal work injuries and illnesses occurred in Illinois private and public industries respectively.

Businessman suffering from wrist pain in office. Workers' comp nerve damage settlement
Workers' Compensation

How Much Is a Workers’ Comp Nerve Damage Settlement?

You may need to know the value of a workers’ comp nerve damage settlement if you or a loved one suffered a work-related injury that caused nerve damage. It is hard to determine the actual amount of a workers’ comp nerve damage settlement in Chicago, Illinois, because each case is unique. Consequently, each settlement may vary depending on the specifics of your case.

Doctor helping manual worker with an arm injury at the metal industry factory. Indirect costs for workplace accidents
Workers' Compensation

What Are the Indirect Costs for Workplace Accidents in Chicago, Illinois?

The indirect costs for workplace accidents in Chicago, Illinois, are uninsured and unbudgeted expenses, including productivity loss and downtime. Other examples include increased insurance premiums, damage to the company’s reputation, and loss of employee morale.

Get a FREE Consultation:
We want to earn your business.

    Lawyers logos
    Lawyers logos